A new Methodology for Determining the Market Boundaries and the Monopoly (Dominant) Position of Undertakings in the Market (the “Methodology”) came into effect in Ukraine on 1 August 2026. It replaced the 2002 methodology that had served for over 24 years as the key instrument used by the Antimonopoly Committee of Ukraine (“AMCU” or the “Committee”) to define market boundaries and establish whether a dominant position existed or not.
By way of explaining the need of updating, the AMCU refers to the law enforcement experience accumulated and the urgency of having regard to current international approaches and practices pursued by EU competition authorities. The updated Commission Notice on the definition of the relevant market for the purposes of Union competition law (C/2024/1645 of 22 February 2024) (“EU Commission Notice 2024”) turned out to be one of the key pieces of guidance.
However, it is not merely about refreshing the terminology. While the old approach was more formalized and relied heavily on product characteristics, territory, sales and market share, the new Methodology shifts its focus on assessing actual economic conditions of competition and actual undertaking's position in the market.
Moreover, it is worth noting that since recently the AMCU has been actually using a part of the approaches set forth in the new Methodology. The Committee took due account of actual competitive constraints, entry barriers, potential competition, and other market factors, although technically this had been the case for the 2002 methodology. Therefore, the new Methodology is not all about introducing new tools but ratifying and systematizing the approaches the AMCU has already put into practice.
Below we set up the top 5 changes which we believe will be of the greatest practical significance for undertakings dealing with the AMCU in cases requiring the definition of market boundaries, in particular during the examination of mergers, cases concerning the abuse of a dominant position and anti-competitive concerted practices.
1. A New Approach to Assessing the Product Substitution
The 2002 methodology defined product boundaries based on a group of interchangeable products by analyzing their functional purpose, consumer properties, conditions of use, price, and other characteristics. In doing so, all of these criteria used to be treated as equally weighted.
The new Methodology presents this analysis in more detail, distinguishing clearly between demand-side substitution as the primary criterion and supply-side substitution as a secondary one.
When assessing the demand-side substitution, the AMCU identifies specific product characteristics that are decisive for buyers and assesses whether they willingly switch to an alternative product whenever there is a change in the price, quality, or other conditions of supply. In addition, it can take into consideration, among other things, the actual occurrences when such switch took place, price differences, specific use of the product, and the potential to purchase the product from other suppliers. Such an approach is consistent with the European practice dealing with the demand-side substitution as a fundamental criterion to define product boundaries of the market.
The supply-side substitution is of a supplementary nature, enabling to identify those suppliers who do not currently produce the relevant product but can start producing or selling the same within a period of no more than two years by incurring no significant additional costs or risks. Furthermore, it is sufficient to have even some suppliers who are actually able to do so, provided their potential market entry gives rise to real competitive pressure. To such extent, the AMCU's approach is potentially broader than the European one. EU Commission Notice 2024 proceeds on the basis that most, if not all, suppliers should be able to switch production between products without sunk costs or risks and in the short term. Therefore, the new Methodology does not fully replicate the European approach and its wording may provide undertakings with an additional argument favoring a broader definition of the product market, which, in turn, affects the size of market shares.
In addition, the new Methodology sets out detailed rules to tackle more complex definitions of product boundaries and, specifically, chains of substitution, and complementary and differentiated products. It expressly states that, as a general rule, different stages of product circulation (e.g., distribution, wholesale, and retail) are not combined into a single market. Such an approach, however, is not something new to the AMCU's practice as the Committee used to treat various stages of product circulation as separate markets, while the new Methodology is essentially about standardizing the practice that is already established.
2. SSNIP Test Is Now Officially Part of the Methodology
The new Methodology is now explicit about potential application of the SSNIP (small but significant and non-transitory increase in price) or “hypothetical monopolist” test which is widely used by the European Commission.
It is essentially reduced to assessing whether a hypothetical monopolist would benefit from a small but significant and non-transitory increase in prices. If, consequently, a sufficient number of buyers would switch to an alternative product or supplier within another territory, the market initially defined might be too narrow.
Although, the SSNIP test has a number of limitations. To be more specific, it should not be applied when competition is, in fact, of non-price nature or the actual price already exceeds significantly the competitive level. In the latter case, using an already inflated price as a starting point may artificially expand the market boundaries.
It is important not to confuse the SSNIP test with the 5% price increase set forth in the 2002 methodology: this figure was used to measure time boundaries of the market rather than as the fully-fledged hypothetical monopolist test. Furthermore, the SSNIP test is not entirely new in the light of the AMCU's practice: the Committee approved certain guidelines regarding its application as early as in 2020.
The most notable example is the AMCU's decision made on 5 September 2024 in the merger case involving CRH Ukraine and Dyckerhoff Cement Ukraine PrJSC. Proceeding from SSNIP test results, the Committee found that a small but significant and non-transitory increase in the price of certain cement brand would not prompt most consumers to switch to another brand: a portion of consumers only would agree to such substitution and with respect to interchangeable items only. This served as one of the arguments supporting the conclusion that specific cement brands may be substituted partially, rather than fully, so that the AMCU took this into consideration when granting the merger clearance and authorizing the concerted actions.
The new Methodology effectively integrates this tool directly into the general methodology of market definition.
The price test may yield little useful information if it deals with markets where competition is based primarily on quality, functionality or innovation, or where a specific product is available at no cost. The EU practice in such cases allows for the use of other approaches, such as the SSNDQ (small but significant non-transitory decrease in quality) test to assess the response to a decrease in quality.
Thus, the SSNIP test is not a universal tool, but it provides the AMCU and undertakings with a more structured economic framework for defining market boundaries.
3. Geographic Market Boundaries Without Quantitative Thresholds
The 2002 methodology provided specific quantitative benchmarks. For a regional market, an openness ratio below 30% confirmed that the territorial (geographic) boundaries had been correctly defined, while that exceeding 30% required further analysis. For a nationwide market, the corresponding benchmark was 40%.
The new Methodology does not include such a test. The AMCU must assess the homogeneity of competitive conditions in the relevant territory, based, in particular, on supplier composition in different regions, price levels, trade flows, transportation and other logistics costs, barriers to doing business in other territories, purchasing behaviour, and a supplier's ability to discriminate against customers based on geographic location. This change clearly illustrates the overall logic of the reform: a quantitative indicator gives way to an analysis of whether real competitive boundaries exist between territories.
In recent years, the AMCU has been following a new approach, specifically in the elevator services and electricity markets, these changes thus being rather a legal embodiment of an already established practice than an innovation.
4. HHI and Other Alternative Indicators for Measuring Market Share
Sales volume remains, as before, the basic indicator for measuring market share. However, the new Methodology significantly expands the toolkit for assessing the market structure and the positions of market participants.
Depending on market characteristics, either volume-based or value-based indicators may be used. For example, in the grain storage services market, the AMCU has been taking into account the capacity of the relevant grain elevator for several years now.
The Methodology also explicitly provides for industry-specific indicators for certain industries, including R&D or patent expenditures for innovative sectors, and the number of active users, the frequency of service use or the number of transactions for digital platforms.
A notable new development is the explicit use of the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI) to measure market concentration: above 2,000 indicating a highly concentrated market; between 1,000 and 2,000 corresponding to a moderately concentrated market; and below 1,000 seen as a non-concentrated market. Changes in the HHI may also indicate shifts in the competitive structure.
However, these approaches are not new to the AMCU's practice: the Committee has applied similar thresholds in the past. For example, in the above merger case between CRH Ukraine and Dyckerhoff Cement Ukraine PrJSC, the Committee investigated the change in the HHI in the portland cement market resulting from the merger. The increase in the HHI in the Portland cement market following the merger served as the basis for classifying the market as highly concentrated and imposing behavioural commitments on CRH Ukraine B.V. as a condition for merger clearance.
A similar approach can be seen in the AMCU's guidelines of 11 September 2025 regarding the school bus sales market: based on the participants' market shares, the Committee measured the HHI at 3,034 and characterised the relevant market as highly concentrated with signs of an oligopoly.
Consequently, the new Methodology rather formalises the approach already established in the AMCU's practice, directly incorporating the HHI and the corresponding threshold values into the general market analysis methodology.
On top of this, the Methodology provides for the market concentration ratio CRs as the combined share of several largest participants in the market.
The tools listed above allow for a more accurate consideration of the specifics of a particular market and an assessment of the actual positions of its participants.
5. Counterparty’s Market Power May Indicate the Absence of Dominance
One of the key new provisions protecting undertakings is a separate regulation of countervailing buyer or supplier power.
The new Methodology explicitly provides for an assessment of a customer's or supplier's ability to limit a counterparty's market power. For example, a supplier may hold a significant market share but depend on one or more large buyers capable of quickly switching to a competitor, organising imports, reducing purchases, or otherwise posing a real threat of the supplier losing a significant volume of sales. In such a case, the supplier's ability to independently determine the terms of trade for products on the market may be significantly limited, accordingly affecting its legal classification as a monopolist.
However, the mere existence of a large buyer is not sufficient: its bargaining power must actually and substantially limit the supplier's market power. Therefore, the counterparty's countervailing power is not an automatic “safe harbour” for an undertaking with a large market share; however, if supported by sufficient evidence, it can significantly influence the AMCU's conclusion as to whether it holds a dominant position.
For undertakings, this means the need to build a body of evidence in advance: a negotiation history, instances of customers switching to competitors, key buyers' share of sales, import opportunities, and alternative sources of supply. It is this information that the AMCU will consider when assessing an undertaking's market power.
Key Takeways
The new Methodology is not a technical update, but a change in the AMCU's approach to assessing the market and market power. The analysis becomes more economically oriented: formal criteria are supplemented by an assessment of the real conditions of competition and the behaviour of market participants.
However, most of these approaches are not entirely new to the AMCU's practice: in recent years, the Committee has already actually applied them in its decisions, with the new Methodology largely systematising and legally formalising such practice.
Of particular practical importance will be new approaches to defining the geographic market boundaries and applying the tool such as the countervailing market power of a counterparty. As a result, the market share itself can increasingly less be considered isolated from other factors that determine the company's actual ability to influence the conditions of competition in the market.
For undertakings, this increases the importance of early assessment of their market position and building a body of evidence in case of future interaction with the AMCU. Companies analysing these issues before the AMCU begins its investigation as part of a merger application or investigation of abuse of dominance or anti-competitive concerted practices will have much more opportunities to build a convincing case and defend their position.
Authors: Anna Sisetska, Yevhenii Senchenko, Markiian Kohut